4/22/18

Future Firepower of The IDF 2030

Udi Etzion, a respectable author, wrote an article to the daily Yediot Aharonot magazine, where he describes the technologies the IDF could incorporate by the year 2030, in some way or another.
Similar to the soon-to-be-established American Futures Command, the IDF has committees that plan for the coming years. The objectives for 2020 are advancing on schedule and now they are looking to what will be in the decade that follows.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Laser systems for the protection of ground forces, 2-man "Carmel" tanks, smart helmets for the infantry, drones for medevac, unmanned ammo trucks, and a data analyst for every brigade commander. The IDF is already recruiting the AI and operates more and more autonomous vehicles in the air, land, and sea. But even in 12 years the robots will not replace the combat soldiers and pilots. The army will march on its stomach, only the food will be printed on the field, in portable 3D printers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Even in 2018 it sounds like science fiction, surely in 1978. But this story did happen. 40 years ago RAFAEL had worked on a secret project to develop a laser weapon system for the Sa'ar-5 ships that the navy would later acquire. The project was frozen after it was realized just how much time and resources will be needed for its completion. Only in recent years the US Navy began fielding this system.

So when we start drawing up the plan for what the IDF will acquire by 2030, we have to take into account that not every promising technology matures in the pace that is expected of it, and sometimes the priorities change because of the changing reality in the region. Take for example the presence of Russian and Iranian forces in the north and the growing tensions in Syria that have already caused the re-writing of work plans for the coming years. But even under the limitations of censorship, this is a rare view into the plans and projects that will turn 82-year old IDF into something different than it was in its 70th.

After the revolution of precise weapons in the 90's, and the information revolution of the past decade, the IDF is now facing another revolution: Autonomous fighting. In 2030 we will have the capability to identify targets, classify them, adapt the right type of weapon to them, and give the order of fire.
Once, a ground force could be attacked, identify a target, and request fire on target, and wait 2 hours until it would receive it.
We are on our way to a reality where we will have the capability to employ quick and precise firepower when a man only supervises it. Of course, there is no substitute for a commander who sets the open fire policy depending on the circumstances.

Brig. General Avtalion says "We are dealing in reality. As the prime technologist of the ground forces in the IDF I can tell you that the leap that is happening in AI and processing power could allow these capabilities even earlier. We're talking about a smart network that will be connected to all types of recon, armament, and command centers. It will allow the use of autonomous vehicles and reduce the risk to the combat soldiers. We have a long way to go before we get there, but even today the IDF is a world leader in fielding autonomous capabilities".

Brig. General Avtalion is not the only technologist that believes these autonomous capabilities are achievable within a decade. "There are 3 revolutions that will aid this happen: The leap in AI capabilities, through neuron networks and other means, the ability to create and analyze vast amounts of data, what is called Big Data, and the decreasing cost of processing power", explains Colonel A, commander of Matzpen, the software development unit of the GHQ (General Head Quarters).
"AI could better identify the centers of gravity of the enemy and advise commanders where to attack. Even today we're using AI in the West Bank area. The big challenge becomes how to professionalize and use all the digital data that the system has in every sector. In the military, there are vast amounts of data and one has to know how to extract the relevant data. The brigade commanders of 2030 won't need only a driver and communications operator, but a data analyst as well. Just like there are data analysts in the capital market today."

The move will not be sweeping: Pilots, tank crews, sailors, will continue firing on their own and with their judgement. The Tzayad system (BMS), that is already operational, will be used not only for the control of ground forces but also the control of autonomous systems. For example on borders.", explains head of planning division of the ground forces, Colonel Rami Avudraham.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It is no surprise this is primarily about the ground forces. The understanding that the IDF has for years neglected the ground forces for the sake of the air force and intelligence, was translated by Chief of Staff Gadi Eizenkot to an organized program for the upgrade of the ground forces. Actions that begin today will be completed within a decade and will make the ground forces more technologically advanced than it is today.

This way, for example, by then the program to re-equip the IDF with new howitzers will be completed. The new howitzers, developed by Elbit systems, will have higher rate of fire, less crewmen, more precise firepower, and automatic datalink to location systems (GPS), weather analysis and more.
The new systems will probably be mounted on special wheeled trucks and not on tracked platforms, contrary to the current howitzers.
The army by then will have hundreds of Eitan combat vehicles that will replace some of the M113 that should have been gone a while ago.
And as was reported here earlier, the IDF will set up a new rocket force subordinated to the GHQ, that will base itself on long range rockets up to a range of 300km or more.

The innovations won't stop here. For years the IDF has dragged its feet in the procurement of defense systems. The Army resisted systems like Arrow and Iron Dome, and only started equipping its advanced Merkava 4 tanks with the Trophy APS after the 2nd Lebanon War. 
Today, after they have all proven themselves, they changed approach.

In recent months a new project was initiated to develop a protection system for the ground troops, that will accompany them on the battlefield and enter service in the next decade. "We want to provide the maneuvering troops a protection system against mortars, short range rockets, and drones", explains Colonel Avudraham.
"The system will be based on a laser (Iron Beam), and on kinetic interceptors as well, a product that doesn't exist yet anywhere in the world".
Drones, activated in packs, pose a double threat: They allow terrorists to conduct surveillance and espionage on IDF troops, a capability that once only state actors possessed, and gives them the ability to strike from the air via release of grenades, or "suicide" of HE-carrying drones.

On the other hand, the IDF is set to bolster the aerial capabilities of its ground troops. Elbit's new "Skylark 2" drone, that has already assimilated in the infantry brigades and can provide commanders with 6 hours of continuous footage, will soon be joined by new UAVs, that will reduce the dependence on the air force.
We're talking about armed drones and kamikaze drones, sort of single-use UAVs that can loiter for a very long time before locating a target and detonating on it. If they won't find a target, they can be safely retrieved, refueled, and reused.

By 2030 we'll also take in new advanced drones that will assume a new niche: Communications. To permit all autonomous capabilities, the ground forces will need access to intelligence systems and communications to receive new orders. The new communications array will ensure a steady stream of up-to-date data from the front to the commands and vice versa.
However, the ability to conduct operations independently will be preserved.

Until then, the IDF will be equipped with a significant amount of Merkava 4 Barack tanks, the improved model that will enter serial production in 2020, and will include improvements to its protection, but mostly to identification of targets and their handling whilst connected to an army-wide network.

On the other hand, by 2030 the new vehicles that will replace the Merkava on the production line should mature as well: The "Carmel", an advanced tank that will be operated by 2 men only instead of 4, as well as a family of vehicles based on it.
The real question is whether the conservative IDF will be able to take the dramatic choice to end the production of the classical tank and move on to the 21st century.

Overall, after many years of conservatism and sticking to treads, we could see in the IDF more and more wheeled AFVs. The Eitan IFVs will be joined by smaller, lighter vehicles adapted to fighting in urban areas. It will allow more fighters to mobilize with proper protection. With that in mind, it is clear that by 2030 the IDF will not be able to replace the M113 entirely, such as the one that blew up in Shujaiya in Operation Protective Edge, and many of them will remain in service. But they will only serve as 2nd line vehicles, not to be used by those units who will spearhead the fight.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Sa'ar 6 ships are set to arrive in Israel soon, and by the start of the next decade (20's) they will enter service after being refitted with indigenous systems. They will be used to protect the offshore gas rigs.
These ships will be among the most well armed in the world: Barak 8 missiles of the IAI against super-sonic Yakhont missiles held by Syria and Hezbollah, a naval version of the Iron Dome against rockets aimed at the gas rigs, and a new offensive weapon, Israeli as well.

We are also testing the possibility of arming these ships with long range rockets. These are a naval version of IMI's long range rockets for several hundred kilometers, that will serve as a basis for the IDF's new rocket corps. The Iron Dome didn't need any significant changes to become adapted to naval platforms. If that will be the case for IMI's rockets, and there won't be a need in significant investment in their modification, then they'll make it to the navy.

The navy will also accept by 2030 at least one submarine out of the 3 on order. Although they're built by the same shipyard that built the Dolphin 1 and Dolphin 2 class submarines, they will be different.
In recent years, low frequency sonars are entering the world of submarines, with improved active detection capabilities. There is wider use of radars as well, and satellite identification of submarines has also become available. The answer to these threats is a new design of the body of the submarine, to be 'stealthier' to these means.

The navy plans to complete by 2030 the replacement of the Sa'ar 4.5 ships of the "Nirit" class. Now that the submarine and surface ship corruption case has blown up, the IDF will return to buying its ships at home. That is, build the new surface ships, call them "Sa'ar 7" if you like, in Israel Shipyards facilities in Haifa, that also built the Sa'ar 4.5 ships.
The IDF needs new heavier ships to replace the Sa'ar 4.5 that will increase in weight from 500 tons to 900 tons. A proper candidate could be the "Sa'ar 72" which are redesigned Sa'ar 4.5 ships. The Sa'ar 5 weighing 1,200 tons will be replaced by 2,000 ton Sa'ar 6 ships.

The navy will also try to convince decision makers at the GHQ to increase the number of ships in light of the new presence of not-so-friendly navies in the Mediterranean, such as the Russian fleet. In 2030 the Sa'ar 5 will be the backbone of the fleet, almost 40 years in age, and they will also need either refurbishment and modernization, or replacement.

Article: Here.

4/13/18

Eitan completes series of mobility tests

Due to enter service by the end of 2020 if not sooner, the Eitan is quickly getting closer and closer to completion of its development phase, with recently reaching a milestone of rigorous mobility tests.
Tests included driving in all of Israel's types of terrain from the wet and muddy north, to the hot deserts of the south.
The next major milestones of its development will include integration of a turret with an APS, as well as operational tests in exercises with the Nahal infantry brigade that is set to absorb them first.
The turret is developed jointly for the Namer and Eitan, and at least one prototype was integrated and tested on the Namer. Due to systems commonality between the Namer and Eitan, the development of the turret and testing on both will accelerate the process for the Eitan. 
Nahal brigade has already started testing the prototype as well a while ago, and may soon implement them into wider exercises as more prototypes are built for that purpose.



It is worth noting that another major component of the Eitan - The Iron Vision Head Mounted Display that provides an Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR) view, enabling looking through the vehicle and laying important information on the display wherever the operator is looking, has been tested already last year on the Merkava 4 both in its methods of operation and its technical capabilities. 
Thus, the Eitan is in very advanced stages of its development.

4/4/18

Barak MBT update

I don't really know why it was always marked as a draft and never published, but I think it's still relevant even though it's from November last year (2017):

A new article from "Ynet News" adds new info on the Barak and other programs.
Just a reminder, Barak is an upgraded Merkava 4M. 

It's in Hebrew, but I have taken upon myself to translate the important bits here (some new, some old, I will mark it):

1)The Barak weighs 70 tons. (new)

Ex: In Israel, exact figures are almost never given. It's not because it's OPSEC, but because that's the sort of mentality here. Only the engineers will handle that, and the plebs get rounded numbers. So it could mean about 69, or it could be 73. 
However up until now it's always been 60-65 tons, so we could see some solid amount of equipment added to the tank, which will be interesting. On the downside, it means weight reduction measures probably weren't taken and I shouldn't explain why excessive weight is bad.

2)Utilizes an AI-managed "mission computer". (new/old)

Ex: Okay so we've heard plenty of times that many actions will be automated, and that means AI. It was said however mostly in the context of the firing loop. Now they say the mission computer, otherwise known as BMS, will automatically manage certain comms with other assets that will also include the Namers and Eitans among others. Info that was previously manually input by the TC (commander). 
The AI will be able to make various decisions based on the targets it identifies, whether based on the optics or the APS, and advise the crew on certain actions, and make terrain-mapping related decisions such as pointing optimal firing positions or dangerous areas.

3)Female voice selected to alert crews via BMS. (new)

Ex: Easy to distinguish from a male voice, so it won't blend in with the crew's voices, and the crew will not ignore it (they tend to ignore messages from crewmen). Among the alerts it will give are "Missiles", "Short range ATGM", and "Turning over" which means it will not only alert the crew of the type of threat and thus approximate time to impact, but also of terrain related issues to minimize accidents.

4)It was tested as a fully autonomous vehicle. (new)

Ex: But there is no operational requirement, for obvious reasons, so it's merely a test. 

5)Hybrid powerplant. (new)

Ex: To cope with the higher weight and to save on fuel, hybrid is the way to go. This could also give it an amazing torque and make it a "little" speed demon. And as an environmentalist it really gives me some relief.

6)IronVision helmet system tested last month (October). (old)

Ex: I thought it was scheduled to be tested in April, but nonetheless it's good news it happened. The date for operational fielding has remained unchanged, and even rounded down to 2020, so there's no delay but a re-scheduling. 

7)IronVision to be tested soon on Company-sized force. (new)

Ex: Means less time required for full operational testing, if they segment the operational testing phases to do in parallel with the program.

8)Starting next year, 3 times as many Trophy-equipped vehicles will be manufactured as this year. (new)

Ex: While the production rate is still minimal, to keep the work stable and allow to double the output when needed urgently, the front-line units will benefit greatly and at a quick rate from this decision. It also comes in light of the recent contract for 1,000 Trophy systems, and the decision to not only equip the Namers and Eitans with it, but also the Merkava 3.

3/16/18

Elbit's Howitzer Turret Demonstrator

Elbit has recently shown its turret prototype to the public, which was likely used to demonstrate its automatic loading system to the observers.


Other than the photo, no additional information was released, other than repeating the same that the acquisition of howitzers is the central project for the IDF for the following years.

However there is something to take from this photo.
First, it shows that the system itself will be turreted, and not open as was the ATMOS.
Second, we can see that the turret itself is rather short, so the ammo capacity may be a bit low.

What remains now for the program is to finalize the turret, select a platform (wheeled), integrate the turret into the platform, and name the vehicle.

3/11/18

Israeli Gov't Approves Plan to Purchase Howitzers and IFVs

The cabinet approved this evening (11.03.18) an MoD and IDF plan for strengthening the ground arm, which includes 2 main projects that were decided in the Gideon multi-year plan (2015-2020): The purchase of 'hundreds' of Eitan combat vehicles, and the development of a new self propelled howitzer.

Eitan

On the Eitan, it was said it would enter service with the Nahal light infantry brigade in 2019, and will steadily start replacing M113 in 2020. Nahal was chosen to lead the Eitan project by being the first to test it. 
MANTAK say the Eitan will be the world's most advanced and protected wheeled combat vehicle, basing itself on technologies developed for the Merkava and Namer, and being designed with an open architecture to allow easy integration of upgrades in the future.
And its main advantage over the Namer would be its rapid rate of production.

MoD and IDF refrained from telling how many vehicles exactly will they need, which may be due to the fact that they have yet to see how much the budget allows them. Ideally, it would replace the M113 in as many roles as possible, while in some roles a light armored vehicle, preferably the JLTV, would replace the M113. 

The plan spans a decade, so even if the production rate of the Eitan is similar to the Namer, we can expect at least 300 vehicles. But it won't be, and will likely be twice as fast, which could mean north of 600 vehicles. Of course, many of them will not be frontline vehicles. 

MoD's contract with RAFAEL includes ~1,000 Trophy systems, of which ~90 will go to Merkava 3 tanks, ~600 will be evenly split between Merkava 4 and Namer vehicles, which leaves ~300 for the Eitan over the course of a decade. 
Admittedly, the IDF was only supposed to present its recommendations for an APS (Iron Fist or Trophy) in January 2018, which is long after the contract with RAFAEL was signed, so it remains until the 2018 fiscal report to understand how many more Trophy-equipped Eitans will we see.

SPH

MoD approves the continued project to develop and produce the next generation howitzer for the IDF, and promises that within the following decade, the IDF ground arm will undergo a revolution. 
Indeed, the howitzers are long overdue, and should have been produced and enter service over a decade ago! But budget cuts happened. Thankfully, the Gideon plan seems to be on track from start to end.

Oddly, as opposed to other programs in the IDF, the new howitzer entered prototype stage a while ago and begun test firing as well, without the public knowing the Hebrew name of the system, or seeing a prototype. The Eitan, Namer, Carmel, and Barak, were all named at the very early stages of their program and prototypes/concepts were shown very early on as well.
The fact that the IDF has only very recently concluded it would be best for it to make a first batch of wheeled howitzers shows the development program is still lagging behind, and Elbit's promises to get the system ready within half a year to one and a half years (in the worst case), were broken.

It is however important to understand that Elbit is now tasked with 2 development programs - 1 for a wheeled howitzer, 1 for a tracked howitzer. 

The news here, are that the project can now proceed as planned. It was previously stalled as the MoD had to review it for fears of corruption, and due to a new law that calls for routine program reviews for deals worth 100 million NIS and 400 million NIS, each with different parameters set for the reviews.

Now, considering the fact that they claim a decade will be needed for the full (?) transition, and the facts that today there are ~300 howitzers in service, of which 100 will be cut as the new ones will be able to more than compensate for the lower numbers, we're looking at a production rate of roughly 20 units per year. A more precise figure would likely be 24 howitzers, which would equate to 2 battalions per year, or if there are any plans to produce new dedicated ammo carriers, then 12 howitzers and 6-12 carriers which would equate to 1 battalion.

Source:
https://www.inn.co.il/News/News.aspx/368213

3/9/18

100 first Israeli howitzers to be wheeled

As reported by YnetNews, the IDF will purchase the howitzers in multiple batches, the 100 first units of which are going to be wheeled, and perhaps semi-automatically loaded, although the wording is tricky on the last part.

The new howitzer will be built in an initial batch of 100 vehicles and will be based on a wheeled chassis. Follow-on howitzers may be based on tracked vehicles.
Now, I don't quite remember the exact numbers, but if I'm not wrong, there are, in the IDF:
4 artillery brigades - 2 active, 2 reserve.
Each brigade consists of 4 battalion of howitzers each.
The 2 active brigades are both split with 2 active battalions and 2 reserve battalions in each of them.
This puts us at 4 active battalions, and 12 reserve battalions.

So there are:
Active - 72 howitzers.
Reserve - 216 howitzers.



Each howitzer will be manned by a yet undetermined number of crewmen ranging from 3 to 5, and an overall reduction of 25% to 40% is envisioned, though yet unclear whether it refers to manpower, vehicles, or both.
My assumption is that each vehicle will be manned by 3 men, while another 2 (for a total of 5) will be in the ammo carrier vehicle. This is because it's normal to say the M109 has a crew of 9 to 11 (9 in the vehicle, and 2 in the resupply vehicle).

It is assumed that the typical battalion will reduce to 12 vehicles from 18, so a batch of 100 vehicles will be enough to fully equip 8 battalions, which are 2 whole brigades. And another 4 vehicles will be left for testing and demonstrations.

And of course, it's likely the 2nd batch of 100 vehicles, which will complete the transition of the artillery corps to a new howitzer, will be based on a tracked platform. If that will be the case, the wheeled platforms will be transferred to the reservists, and the tracked platforms will take their place in the active brigades.

This is a good move for 2 main reasons:
1)Tracked howitzers are only needed for maneuver combat. With a total of 192 howitzers (after the transition), hardly half will be required to maneuver anywhere. So it would be ideal if the reservists will have a system that will be easier and cheaper to maintain. A wheeled platform cuts down expenses tremendously.
2)Wheeled platforms are easier and faster to make, not only cheaper. So it would allow the IDF to re-equip its artillery forces before the M109 turn into rust buckets.


The decision to make them semi-automatic may be driven by the need to ramp up production to make up for lost time. The M109 had to be gone a long time ago, so even if the solution is not optimal, it's better than what there is now. But again, it is possible Ynet made a mistake in their reporting, as they said the system could also require no human input in the loading sequence.

The 2nd batch would also likely be with an automatic loading system, as the 2nd batch would not be as urgent, and as was said earlier that Elbit will strive for the maximum level of automation.

Plus, along with the fact that the wheeled and semi automatic howitzers will be used by the reservists most of the time, there is no real loss of capability here. They could be used in places where a high volume of fire isn't exactly necessary, or stay behind just in case a multi-front war begins.

2/23/18

Merkava 3M

Announced last year concurrently with the announcement on the Merkava 4 Barak development, the Merkava 3 is set to become the 3M and receive the Trophy system. The project will take about 3 years, and will cover the 188th active armor brigade.

There has been some confusion around this topic. Some thought the IDF intends to equip the entirety of the Merkava 3 brigades with Trophy. It does not. I'll try to explain why.


The armored corps consists of 4 active armored brigades, and 8 in reserve. Those who finish their service are transferred to the reserve brigades where they undergo training to gain proficiency in the new tanks they're operating, because usually reservists' tanks are older and require time to get used to. The bigger the gap, the less effective they are after the transition. A serviceman on a Merkava 4M, the most technologically advanced MBT in the IDF, and one of the most advanced in the world, will face a serious shock if he's transferred to an early 1980's Merkava 2. All the advanced features he got used to, the tank's speed, its firepower options, the living conditions, the aiding devices in his previous station, are all gone.
For this reason, the IDF does not equip its active brigades first and only then the reservists. It zigzags between active and reserve.
The Merkava 3 brigade is also needed because its servicemen will have an easier time integrating in the 2 remaining Merkava 2 brigades and another Mark 3A brigade. It's very much possible that the IDF will choose to keep the Merkava 3 in active service for at least another 5 to 8 years, until the Merkava 2 tanks are either completely phased out, or one remaining that would be replaced by these Mark 3.

At the moment there is 1 fully equipped reserve brigades with Merkava 4A/B tanks, and another one is in the middle of its transition.

Armored Corps Brigades
Tag
Name
No#  
Division  
Command  
Equipment
Active Brigades
7thArmoredBrigade.svg
Storm from Golan
7
36th
North
Merkava 4M
Hativa188.PNG
Barak
188
36th
North
Merkava 3D Baz
תג יחידה 401.svg
Iron Tracks
401
162nd
South 
Merkava 4M
תג חטיבה 460.svg
Bnei Or
460
80th
South 
Merkava 4M and 3D Baz (also instructional)
Reserve Brigades
Kiryati.svg
Kiryati
4
319th
North
Merkava 4
Logo hativa 8.png
Zaken
8
91st
North
Merkava 3A
HarelBrigade.svg
Arel
10
252nd
South
Merkava 2
Brigade 14 sign.svg
Crushers
14
252nd
South
Merkava 3
Logo-hativa-37.png
Oryx
37
162nd
South
Merkava 3D Baz
Logo hativa 514.png
Iron Fist
205
319th
North
Merkava 3D Baz
Logo-hativa-434.png
Yiftach
434
210th
North
Merkava 3D Baz
847ugda.png
Steel Chariots
847
340th
Central
Merkava 2
Transitioning to Merkava 4
            

So back to the Trophy system!

When this brigade will be fully equipped with the Trophy APS in about 3 years, the IDF will simultaneously reach multiple milestones:
1)The entire active arm of the armored corps will be equipped with the Trophy APS.
2)It will have 2 armored divisions worth of APS-equipped combat vehicles.
3)The 36th will have 2 armored brigades with Trophy, and one infantry brigade with Trophy-equipped Namer APCs/IFVs.
4)The 162nd will have 1 armored brigade with Trophy, and 2 infantry brigades with Trophy-equipped Namer and Eitan IFVs.

And of course, by the time the US and Russia only start delivering APS-equipped tanks and AFVs to the frontline units, the IDF will already start transitioning its first APS-equipped tanks to reserve units, in about 2-3 years from now. And will start producing APS-equipped vehicles at a rate of 100 vehicles per year.